Recall Training for Dogs: Teach Your Dog to Come Back

,
Tan dog running towards the camera through a meadow of orange flowers

Reviewed by Megan Richardson, Clinical Animal Behaviourist on 15 November 2026.

Few things are as stressful on a walk as calling your dog and being completely ignored. Whether they are sprinting towards another dog, disappearing into the undergrowth or simply pretending they cannot hear you, poor recall is one of the most commonly reported problems in UK dogs. In a Royal Veterinary College study that followed almost 1,000 UK dogs to 21 months of age, “not coming back when called” was the third most common problem owners reported, behind only pulling on the lead and jumping up (Brand et al., 2024).

A reliable recall is not just a convenience. It is a safety skill that keeps your dog away from roads, livestock and situations where they could get into trouble, and it is the thing that earns them more freedom. The good news is that recall is trainable at almost any age. It is also worth knowing when poor recall is a straightforward training gap, and when it is a sign of something that needs a different approach entirely.

Why doesn’t my dog come when called?

Before you can fix a recall problem, it helps to understand why it breaks down. The most common reasons are:

  • The environment is more rewarding than you are. When your dog weighs up “chase that squirrel” against “go back to my owner”, they will choose whichever has the stronger history of paying off. If coming back has never been made especially worthwhile, it is hard to compete with a running rabbit.
  • Recall has been “poisoned”. If your dog has learned that coming back means the fun ends, because the lead goes on, they leave the park or they get told off, they will start to avoid it. The recall cue needs to predict something good, every time.
  • The cue was never properly taught. Many owners use their dog’s name and hope for the best, without ever systematically building a strong link between a specific recall cue and a guaranteed reward.
  • Over-arousal or emotional state. A dog in a high state of excitement, fear or frustration finds it much harder to respond to a cue than when they are calm.

When poor recall isn’t just a training problem

This is an important distinction that is easy to miss. Most people assume recall is purely a training issue, and often it is. But sometimes a dog who will not come back is telling you something about their emotional state, not just their training history. For example:

  • Predatory behaviour. A dog in a full chase, locked on to a squirrel, rabbit, deer or livestock, is running on a hard-wired sequence of behaviour rather than being disobedient. Once that sequence has started, recall training alone is unlikely to override it. This needs a behaviour assessment to understand the strength of the motivation and build a management and modification plan around it. It is also a serious safety and legal concern around livestock: worrying livestock is an offence, and the law in England and Wales was tightened in March 2026, with wider police powers and no upper limit on the fine (Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) Act 2025).
  • Reactivity or frustration around other dogs. A dog who bolts towards other dogs and ignores every recall attempt may be experiencing frustration-driven arousal that goes well beyond a training gap. They are emotionally overwhelmed, and no amount of practising recall in the garden will address the feeling driving that response. Our guide to reactive dogs explains more, and our Reactive Recovery Programme is built for exactly this.
  • Fear or anxiety. Some dogs run away and will not come back because they are frightened, of a noise, of something in the environment or of their owner’s reaction. A dog who flees in panic needs a very different approach from one who is simply not motivated by their recall cue. See our page on fear and anxiety in dogs.
  • Compulsive or fixated behaviours. A dog who becomes so fixated on something that they are unreachable, staring, stalking or chasing shadows, lights or reflections, may be showing signs of a repetitive or compulsive behaviour that needs clinical assessment, starting with a check-up at your own vet, because repetitive behaviour can have medical causes.

In all of these situations the recall problem is a symptom of something emotional or behavioural, not a gap in training. Trying to fix it with more recall practice alone will not work, and may make things worse if the underlying issue is not addressed.

What you can try at home

If your dog’s recall is a genuine training gap, in other words they are happy, relaxed and simply have not had enough practice, here is how to get started:

  • Choose a new recall cue. If your dog already ignores “come here”, start fresh with a new word or a whistle. This gives you a clean slate without the baggage of a poisoned cue.
  • Start indoors and in the garden. Say your recall cue and, when your dog comes to you, reward them generously with high-value treats such as chicken, cheese or sausage. Practise dozens of times in easy places before you add distractions.
  • Use a long line for safety. A 5–10 metre long line attached to a well-fitted Y-front or H-style harness lets your dog explore while preventing them from rehearsing running off. It is not a retractable lead; it is a safety tool that gives your dog freedom while you build reliability. Attach it to a harness rather than a collar, because every collar type tested in a UK study, including slip leads, put enough pressure on the neck to risk injury when a dog pulls or hits the end of the line (Carter et al., 2020).
  • Make coming back the best thing that happens on the walk. Reward every recall generously, even if it took a moment, and then let them go again. If coming back always means more freedom and more rewards, your dog will want to do it.
  • Never punish a slow recall. If your dog took five minutes to come back, reward them when they finally arrive. Punishing them for returning teaches them that coming back is dangerous, which is the exact opposite of what you need.

You may see electronic “training” collars marketed as a quick fix for recall. The evidence does not support them. In two UK studies of pet dogs referred specifically for recall problems, trainers who focused on reward-based methods achieved recall at least as good as, and on several measures better than, trainers using electronic collars, and with fewer welfare concerns (Cooper et al., 2014; China et al., 2020). Owners who use reward-based methods also report more success with recall than owners who have tried electronic collars (Blackwell et al., 2012). Our post on why the evidence for reward-based training matters explains the wider picture.

For walks in areas with livestock, a reliable recall is particularly important, but even a good recall is not a substitute for a lead near farm animals. Our article on managing dogs around livestock and wildlife covers the legal and practical considerations in more detail.

When to get professional help

One-to-one training

If your dog is relaxed and happy but recall simply has not been taught effectively, one-to-one training with a qualified, reward-based trainer is a great starting point. Our one-hour sessions take place at your home, out on a walk or online, and are delivered by Animal Training Instructors registered with the ABTC. We build a reliable recall from the ground up with a structured plan tailored to your dog and the places you walk. You can read more on our dog training page and the training session Key Facts.

What happens if it turns out to be more than training?

We see this more often than you might expect. An owner comes to us for recall training and, during the session, it becomes clear that the recall problem is actually driven by something emotional: reactivity, predatory behaviour, anxiety or over-arousal that goes beyond what training alone can address.

When this happens, a training session is not the right setting to treat the underlying issue. A dog trainer can teach skills, but assessing and treating behavioural and emotional problems is the job of a Clinical Animal Behaviourist working on veterinary referral. These are different scopes of practice, and getting the right one matters for your dog.

If we identify this during a training session, here is what we do:

  • We explain what we are seeing and why we believe the recall issue has behavioural or emotional roots beyond a training gap.
  • We give you basic first-aid advice: practical steps to keep your dog safe on walks in the short term, such as long-line use, route management and avoiding high-risk situations.
  • We recommend you speak to your vet about a referral for a full behaviour consultation with a Clinical Animal Behaviourist, who can take a detailed history, assess your dog’s emotional state and build a proper behaviour modification plan.

This is an important professional boundary, and we think being upfront about it builds trust. Training is brilliant for teaching skills, but when the problem runs deeper your dog deserves the right level of support. A behaviour consultation can then identify the root cause, and training can complement the plan once the emotional groundwork is in place. We are honest about what progress looks like in our post on whether a behaviourist can “fix” your dog.

Signs that poor recall may be behavioural

Consider a behaviour consultation rather than, or alongside, training if:

  • Your dog’s recall has deteriorated significantly despite consistent training.
  • Your dog becomes so over-aroused around other dogs or other triggers that they are completely unreachable.
  • There is a predatory pattern: your dog chases livestock, wildlife, joggers or cyclists and cannot be called off.
  • Your dog runs away in fear and hides, or their poor recall seems linked to anxiety.
  • The recall issue is part of a bigger picture, including reactivity, difficulty settling or repetitive behaviours.
  • There is a safety concern: your dog has chased livestock, run towards a road or cannot be managed in open spaces.

We’re here to help

A strong recall gives your dog more freedom and keeps them safe. Whether the answer is training, a behaviour assessment or a combination of the two, Second Nature Behaviour can help you work out the right starting point. You can find all of our dog services on our dog behaviour problems page.

For training enquiries, get in touch with us directly. For behaviour concerns, ask your vet to refer you through our online referral form, or give us a call and we will help you work out which service is right for your dog.

References

  • Blackwell, E. J., Bolster, C., Richards, G., Loftus, B. A., & Casey, R. A. (2012). The use of electronic collars for training domestic dogs: Estimated prevalence, reasons and risk factors for use, and owner perceived success as compared to other training methods. BMC Veterinary Research, 8, 93. https://doi.org/10.1186/1746-6148-8-93
  • Brand, C. L., O’Neill, D. G., Belshaw, Z., Dale, F. C., Merritt, B. L., Clover, K. N., Tay, M.-X. M., Pegram, C. L., & Packer, R. M. A. (2024). Impacts of puppy early life experiences, puppy-purchasing practices, and owner characteristics on owner-reported problem behaviours in a UK Pandemic Puppies cohort at 21 months of age. Animals, 14(2), 336. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani14020336
  • Carter, A., McNally, D., & Roshier, A. (2020). Canine collars: An investigation of collar type and the forces applied to a simulated neck model. Veterinary Record, 187(7), Article e52. https://doi.org/10.1136/vr.105681
  • China, L., Mills, D. S., & Cooper, J. J. (2020). Efficacy of dog training with and without remote electronic collars vs. a focus on positive reinforcement. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 7, 508. https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2020.00508
  • Cooper, J. J., Cracknell, N., Hardiman, J., Wright, H., & Mills, D. (2014). The welfare consequences and efficacy of training pet dogs with remote electronic training collars in comparison to reward based training. PLOS ONE, 9(9), e102722. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0102722
  • Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) Act 2025, c. 32. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2025/32

← Back to the blog